Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding Sam's Club's product selection strategy has led to the removal of certain products, including those from the brand "Panpan," which faced accusations of masquerading as an international brand [1][3][15] Group 1: Product Controversy - Sam's Club has faced criticism for its product selection, particularly regarding the brand "Panpan," which was accused of using a misleading brand name [1][3] - Following customer dissatisfaction, Sam's Club quickly removed the "Panpan" products from its shelves [1] - The "Panpan" brand is registered by Panpan Food, which claims to provide high-quality products for consumers [1][13] Group 2: Brand Naming Practices - Products from Panpan sold at Sam's Club did not prominently display the brand name, leading to confusion among consumers [3][5] - Other brands, such as Chacha and Ganyuan, also employed similar strategies by using English names for their products, which were not clearly identified as their own [7][9] - Ganyuan's products had a more subtle branding approach, with the brand name less visible on the packaging [11] Group 3: Market Performance - Panpan Food reported a 50% increase in sales for its "Panpan" brand in Southeast Asia, which constitutes 80% of its export market share [15] - The company has been focusing on expanding its business in Southeast Asia, with key markets including Thailand, Myanmar, Cambodia, and the Philippines [15] - Panpan Food ranked 63rd in the 2024 list of the top 100 private enterprises in Fujian Province, with a revenue of 8.16 billion yuan [15]

Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the recent backlash against Sam's Club for removing popular products like low-sugar snacks and replacing them with items that consumers find less appealing, leading to dissatisfaction among members [1][3][9]. Product Changes - Sam's Club has recently made significant adjustments to its product offerings, including the removal of high-repurchase-rate items such as sun cakes and low-sugar egg yolk pastries, while introducing new products like low-sugar snacks and oatmeal cakes [1][9]. - Specific products that have been removed include the low-sugar Holi-Ryo pie and the cow mushroom konjac, which were previously popular among consumers [5][10]. Consumer Reactions - Many consumers expressed frustration on social media, feeling that Sam's Club is not providing value for their membership fees by offering products easily available elsewhere [3][9]. - The high approval rating of the removed Holi-Ryo pie, which had a 93.6% positive feedback rate, highlights the disconnect between consumer preferences and the company's product strategy [9]. Company Response - Walmart, the parent company of Sam's Club, acknowledged the feedback from members regarding product selection and stated that it would consider this input in future product strategies [11][12]. - Sam's Club has also indicated that it is aware of the recent public sentiment and plans to hold high-level meetings to discuss potential responses to the backlash [15]. Product Customization - Some brands, such as Holi-Ryo and Lulumei, have confirmed that their products are specially customized for Sam's Club, tailored to meet the preferences of its membership base [14][16]. - The introduction of these customized products is part of a strategy to differentiate offerings and cater to health-conscious consumers [14].

Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the recent controversy surrounding Sam's Club due to the removal of popular products and the introduction of new items, leading to consumer dissatisfaction and questions about the selection standards of the store [1][2][5]. Group 1: Product Changes and Consumer Reactions - Sam's Club has faced backlash from consumers for discontinuing high-repurchase-rate products like sun cakes and low-sugar egg yolk pastries, while introducing new items such as low-sugar Holley Friend pies and other products that are perceived as less desirable [2][4]. - The removal of the Holley Friend pie, which was marketed as having "80% less sugar" and "30% more cocoa," has particularly drawn criticism, with a price of 49.9 yuan for a box of 48 pieces and a high approval rating of 93.6% from over 9,000 reviews [11][12]. - Consumers have expressed feelings of being treated unfairly, questioning whether their membership fees are justified when they can find similar products elsewhere [4][5]. Group 2: Business Performance and Membership Structure - Sam's Club, a subsidiary of Walmart, has over 800 stores globally and is a significant revenue source for Walmart, with net sales in China reaching $6.7 billion (approximately 48.02 billion yuan), a year-on-year increase of 22.5% [14][15]. - The annual membership fee for regular members is 260 yuan, while premium members pay 680 yuan [15]. - The company has been expanding its store presence, adding seven new locations in the past 12 months, and has maintained strong growth in both membership and e-commerce sales [15]. Group 3: Market Positioning and Consumer Expectations - Experts suggest that differentiation is crucial for membership warehouse stores, as consumers expect unique products that are not available in regular retail channels [13][16]. - Quality has become a key factor for Chinese consumers, overshadowing traditional considerations like brand and price, which has contributed to the success of stores like Sam's Club [16].

Core Viewpoint - Recent product adjustments by Sam's Club have led to consumer dissatisfaction, particularly regarding the removal of popular items in favor of more common products, raising questions about the selection criteria [1][10][17]. Group 1: Consumer Reactions - Many consumers expressed disappointment over the removal of favored products like rice pudding and low-sugar egg yolk pastry, stating that they are now offered items easily found in local supermarkets [3][8]. - Some customers have even reached out to Sam's headquarters, requesting the return of their preferred specialty foods [6]. - The sentiment among members is that they are being sold products that do not justify the membership fee, leading to feelings of being taken advantage of [10][22]. Group 2: Product Changes and Quality Concerns - Sam's Club has recently introduced new products in collaboration with popular brands, but the lack of brand recognition on some items has caused confusion and dissatisfaction among members [17]. - The newly launched low-sugar Good Friend pie, priced at 49.9 yuan for 48 pieces, received negative reviews for being overly sweet despite its low-sugar label [12][14]. - The recent product adjustments have led to a decline in consumer trust, as members feel that the quality and uniqueness of offerings are diminishing [17][22]. Group 3: Membership and Market Position - Sam's Club operates with an annual membership fee of 260 yuan for regular members and 680 yuan for premium members, positioning itself as a leading membership warehouse globally with over 800 stores [20]. - According to Pacific Securities, Sam's Club has achieved double-digit growth by catering to the differentiated needs of middle-class families, focusing on high-quality and cost-effective products [20]. - Experts emphasize that differentiation and product quality are essential for membership warehouse stores to maintain their value proposition and consumer loyalty [22].

同日，好丽友相关负责人回应南都湾财社记者称，相关产品为山姆特供，记者亦联系采访盼盼、溜溜 梅、徐福记等相关负责人，截至发稿前未得到回应。 山姆上新好丽友、沪溪河、盼盼等 网友质疑是否也能在普通超市购买 近期，多名网友在社交平台反映，山姆下架了一些回购率高的产品，与此同时上新了好丽友、卫龙、沪 溪河、盼盼等产品，有网友质疑山姆选品策略，称充值会员并不是为了购买在普通商超也能买到的产 品。 近日，山姆会员商店因上架好丽友、盼盼、徐福记、溜溜梅等多品牌产品遭到部分会员反对。7月15 日，#山姆下架多款口碑商品但上新好丽友#、#山姆越来越像沃尔玛#等话题登上微博热搜。部分会员质 疑，普通超市就能买到的产品，为何要在山姆花钱开卡购买？ 7月15日，南都湾财社记者走访广州一家山姆会员商店了解到，山姆确实于近期上架了好丽友、沪溪河 等产品，但记者注意到，在山姆销售的盼盼等产品，对应的包装及价格标签都没有显著的品牌标志。 针对近期舆情，7月15日，沃尔玛相关负责人回应南都湾财社记者称，已经关注到了社交网络上关于山 姆选品问题的讨论，并已纳入后续选品策略的考量中。 此外，亦有网友发帖称，山姆上架的一款"panpan法式小泡芙" ...