Core Viewpoint - The article emphasizes the rapid evolution of AI music generation products, highlighting the need for a comprehensive evaluation of their capabilities in real-world applications [2][3]. Group 1: Overview of AI Music Generators - Seven representative AI music generation products were selected for evaluation, including Suno, ElevenLabs, Udio, and others, showcasing a mix of international and Chinese companies [5][6]. - The evaluation focused on practical tasks relevant to everyday users, assessing aspects like generation speed, cost, seamless looping, lyric matching, Chinese pronunciation, and export formats [4][9]. Group 2: Evaluation Process - The evaluation involved five representative use cases to simulate the process of generating music from scratch, ensuring a realistic assessment of each product's performance [9][10]. - All products were tested under default settings to reflect the experience of ordinary users without any adjustments [10]. Group 3: Performance Results - For background music suitable for corporate events, Suno and ElevenLabs were noted for their alignment with commercial needs, although neither supported seamless looping [13]. - In the meditation music category, ElevenLabs, Udio, and Suno excelled in creating a natural atmosphere, with Suno particularly noted for its emotional control [17][20]. - For suspenseful horror film openings, Suno and ElevenLabs demonstrated strong atmospheric creation, while Udio was recognized for its intense rhythm suitable for promotional content [18][23]. - In the R&B category, Suno and Udio showed strong structural awareness, effectively completing song structures based on provided lyrics [28]. - For mimicking Jay Chou's style, Suno and Mureka performed best, but overall results indicated significant challenges in accurately replicating specific musical styles [32][34]. Group 4: Product Differentiation - The AI music products displayed clear differentiation in functionality, creative paths, and application scenarios, contrasting with the more integrated approach seen in AI video products [36]. - Suno was highlighted as a versatile platform with excellent stability and completion rates, while ElevenLabs focused on visualizing song structures for precise control [37]. Group 5: Future Predictions - The future of AI music products is expected to follow two parallel paths: one aimed at professional creators for efficiency and inspiration, and the other catering to general users for quick content generation [40]. - Innovations may lead to collaborative AI systems that assist in music creation, moving beyond simple one-click generation to more interactive processes [41]. - The development of clearer copyright regulations and style imitation guidelines is anticipated as the industry matures [42].

Core Insights - The rise of AI musicians is significantly disrupting the traditional music industry, with AI-generated artists like Aventhis and The Devil Inside gaining substantial popularity on streaming platforms [2][3][7] - AI-generated music is characterized by high production efficiency, allowing AI artists to release multiple tracks in a short time, which contrasts sharply with the slower output of human musicians [7][8] Industry Impact - AI musicians are rapidly capturing market share, with Aventhis releasing three albums and 57 tracks in just four months, showcasing a production speed that human artists struggle to match [7] - The emergence of AI-generated content is leading to a chaotic landscape in the music industry, raising questions about copyright and legal implications [11][12] Streaming Platforms - Deezer has taken the initiative to label AI-generated content, while other platforms like Spotify, Apple Music, and Amazon Music have remained silent on the issue [12] - Over 20,000 AI-generated tracks are uploaded daily on Deezer, with AI-produced audio accounting for 18% of total uploads in April [6] Legal and Copyright Issues - The legality of AI-generated music is under scrutiny, with companies like Suno and Udio facing lawsuits for allegedly using copyrighted songs without authorization [11] - The U.S. Copyright Office has stated that AI-generated works do not hold copyright unless there is sufficient human input, leading to uncertainty regarding ownership and rights [12]