特里芬难题
Search documents
中金缪延亮:国际货币体系的十个“未解之谜”
中金点睛· 2025-06-08 23:57
Core Viewpoint - The current international monetary system is undergoing profound changes due to the long-term disorderly expansion of U.S. public debt, the "weaponization" of the dollar during the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and various policy proposals during the Trump 2.0 era, which erode the credibility of the dollar as the world's reserve currency [2]. Group 1: Triffin Dilemma Misinterpretations - The "Triffin Dilemma" has evolved into two versions post-Bretton Woods: one concerning the current account and the other regarding "safe assets," both of which contain significant misunderstandings [4][13]. - Misconceptions include confusing net capital with total capital inflows, mixing "earned" and "borrowed" foreign exchange reserves, and conflating bilateral with multilateral capital flows [17][19][20]. - The supply of dollar liquidity is not necessarily linked to the U.S. current account deficit, as the U.S. maintained a current account surplus for about 30 years after becoming the primary reserve currency [14][21]. Group 2: U.S. Stocks as Safe Assets - Overseas funds have shifted from U.S. Treasury bonds to U.S. stocks, leading to the disappearance of the equity risk premium in the S&P 500, indicating that investors now view U.S. stocks as safe assets [5][23]. - This shift is driven by declining safety perceptions of U.S. debt and the stable long-term growth of U.S. stocks, with significant capital inflows into the U.S. stock market [26][30]. Group 3: U.S. Reserve Currency Status - The U.S. is unlikely to relinquish its status as the world's reserve currency due to the substantial benefits it provides, including the international seigniorage revenue [6][32]. - The unique asset-liability structure of the U.S. allows it to benefit from dollar depreciation, effectively transferring payment burdens globally [36][39]. Group 4: Declining Economic Share vs. Rising Financial Dominance - While the U.S. share of the real economy is declining, its share in international finance is increasing, primarily due to the offshore dollar being the most important financing currency and onshore dollars being viewed as safe assets [7][40][44]. - The expansion of cross-border capital flows has outpaced trade growth, reinforcing the dollar's financial position [46]. Group 5: Dollar Cycles - The dollar exhibits cyclical characteristics influenced by fundamentals, policies, and capital flows, with positive feedback mechanisms amplifying these cycles [8][48][52]. - The dollar's appreciation impacts global economies asymmetrically, benefiting the U.S. while constraining other economies [53]. Group 6: The Dollar's Global Impact - The U.S. often emerges unscathed from global crises, with the adverse effects disproportionately affecting non-U.S. economies due to the asymmetrical impact of U.S. monetary policy [56][58]. - The dollar's status as a reserve currency provides the U.S. with unique advantages, including lower financing costs and the ability to conduct fiscal stimulus without immediate repayment pressures [57]. Group 7: Need for an International Monetary System - The current trend towards a multi-polar world raises questions about the necessity of an international monetary system, with the dollar still playing a central role in global trade and finance [62][63]. - A multi-currency system may be preferable to a non-system, as it allows for currency competition and provides space for emerging currencies like the renminbi [64]. Group 8: Transitioning to a Multi-Currency System - Transitioning from a dollar-centric system to a multi-currency system requires policy coordination among major currency issuers and flexible exchange rate arrangements [11][65].
中金 | 美元之困:当“火星”遇上“水星”
中金点睛· 2025-06-08 23:57
中金研究 近期市场对美元走势的关注度大幅上升,不仅关心其短期走势,也关注其长期地位。 美元成为国际储备货币 是市场选择,也是制度安排。一个货币如何成为国际货币 ,学 术领域有经济与非经济视角,Barry Eichengreen等(2019)形象地将之比喻为"水星假说"与"火星假说"。所谓的"水星假说",强调经济因素(比如 经济规模、资本市场发达程度等)决定某货币是否能成为国际货币;所谓的"火星假说",强调地缘政治等非经 济因素的作用。 一些人士也指出(如法国财政部长德斯坦),美元受益于其国际储备货币地位,享有低融资成本等"特权"。在 不考虑其他因素的情况下,美国债务与其他国家的债务相比,能享受更低的利率。不管是"火星假说"视角还 是"水星假说"视角,美元的国际地位面临的挑战在增多。从"水星假说"视角来看,我们认为美国财政赤字居高 不下,债务风险增加,美元的信用受到质疑。从"火星假说"视角来看,美国为其盟友提供安全保障的意愿与能 力下降,我们认为降低了美元的"安全溢价"。但是在中短期内,我们认为美元在全球储备中仍占据很重要的地 位。 点击小程序查看报告原文 美元成为国际储备货币是市场选择,也是制度安排 不同的货 ...
美国下一步将拿谁“开刀”?, 36万亿美债, 崩盘进入倒计时
Sou Hu Cai Jing· 2025-06-06 00:47
Group 1 - The countdown to a potential U.S. debt default is underway, with significant economic turmoil expected in the coming months, particularly around the U.S. government's plans to impose tariffs and the expiration of the U.S.-China trade truce [1][2] - The U.S. national debt has reached $36 trillion, hitting the debt ceiling, forcing the government to borrow new debt to pay off old debt, which has led to difficulties in long-term bond auctions requiring yields as high as 5% to attract investors [2][4] - The Federal Reserve's quantitative easing (QE) since the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in a cycle where maturing low-interest bonds must be replaced with high-interest debt, potentially leading to annual interest payments of $1.5 trillion if all debt is refinanced at 4% [2][6] Group 2 - Concerns about the U.S. debt market have been echoed by major financial figures, including JPMorgan's CEO Jamie Dimon, who warned of cracks in the market and the inevitability of a crisis, suggesting that preparations are being made for potential fallout [4][5] - The U.S. trade deficit has dramatically increased from $600 billion to over $900 billion since 2020, reflecting a 50% rise, which parallels the increase in national debt, highlighting the challenges posed by the Triffin dilemma [6][7] - The U.S. may resort to aggressive economic measures against China, the EU, and other global economies to address the debt crisis, potentially impacting domestic technology giants as well [9][11]
36万亿美债,崩盘进入倒计时,美国下一步或将拿中国“开刀”?
Sou Hu Cai Jing· 2025-06-05 13:43
Group 1 - The U.S. debt crisis is approaching a critical point, with a potential default looming in the next hundred days due to the need to raise the debt ceiling by August [1][3] - The current U.S. debt has reached $36 trillion, and the government is relying on borrowing to manage its obligations, facing challenges in long-term bond auctions that require high yields to attract buyers [1][3] - If all $36 trillion of U.S. debt were to be replaced with a 4% interest rate, annual interest payments would amount to $1.5 trillion, indicating a significant financial burden [3] Group 2 - The root of the U.S. debt crisis lies in the Triffin Dilemma, which necessitates continuous debt expansion to maintain the dollar's status as the world's reserve currency [5][7] - The U.S. trade deficit has dramatically increased from $600 billion to over $900 billion since 2020, reflecting a more than 50% rise, while the national debt has similarly surged by over 50% [5] - The U.S. may resort to aggressive economic measures against other economies, including China and the EU, to replenish its finances, potentially impacting global economic stability [7]
经历了过山车行情,黄金价格未来走势如何?
Sou Hu Cai Jing· 2025-06-05 12:34
5月即将过去,本月万众瞩目的黄金市场呈现剧烈震荡行情,国际金价经历了显著的"过山车"式波动。5月初,纽约金价一度跌至3,123美元/盎 司,随后因为地缘冲突升级(中东局势紧张、俄乌和谈停滞)推动避险需求激增,于5月6日最高触及3,448美元/盎司的高位。然后一路下滑, 截至5月29日上午,已经跌到3,285美元/盎司。 实物消费端也出现了明显的调整,国内的婚庆开始流行"租三金",深圳水贝黄金回收量同比增长超过200%,这似乎说明消费者已经觉得黄金 的价格太高了,消费欲望开始减退。这种行情开始让很多投资者变得焦虑,手里的黄金是否要抛售,还是继续买入? 让我们来看看本轮黄金市场的根本驱动因素。本轮黄金牛市与之前不太一样,以往大部分时间,黄金价格主要是受到美联储货币政策驱动的。 由于黄金以美元计价,美元走强直接削弱了黄金的吸引力。历史数据显示,美元指数每上涨1%,金价平均下跌0.8%。 不过本轮黄金大牛市,却主要是受到政治因素的影响。首先就是在俄乌冲突爆发后,西方国家冻结了俄罗斯在西方的资产,引发第三世界国家 央行恐慌,开始将美元欧元资产转向黄金。 图1:各国央行和大机构投资者在西方冻结俄罗斯央行海外资产前后在伦敦 ...
美债崩盘,100天倒计时
Jin Tou Wang· 2025-06-05 09:59
2020年,美国受疫情冲击开启无限QE,美联储开动印钞机,每月上千亿地购买各期限国债。而现在, 美国在前两轮低利率周期发的国债陆续到期,只能高利率发新债去置换。如果36万亿美债未来全都换成 4%利率,光利息支出每年就有1.5万亿美元。如果再大规模增发国债,就隐隐有种高息QE的味道了,开 启一个以5%利率印钞购债的壮举,就像一个走投无路的人被迫借下高利贷,解决燃眉之急,但未来违 约的风险更大了。所以哪怕美债上限再度提高,美债危机的风险也只是暂时解除,未来的风险反而更 高。 有人可能会说,年年都说美债要爆,但为什么美债还是好好的? 数十年来,投资人把美国政府国债视为终极安全资产,每当危机来袭,即使是美国本土爆发的危机,例 如2008年次贷危机,美国国债买气有增而无减,因为全球投资人相信美国政府严肃治国,不履行债务的 情境难以想像。 但现在川普2.0政府执政,关税政策和大而美法案吓坏金融市场,导致诡异现象:美债收益率攀升,美 元却往下栽。 一场悬在人类经济之上的无声风暴正在酝酿——美国国债总额已突破36万亿美元,这座堆积如山的债务 大厦,随时可能在一声巨响中轰然倒塌。 目前,美债违约已经进入倒计时,之后100天,全 ...
中信证券首席经济学家明明:全球经济面临通胀与债务再平衡的核心挑战
Xin Lang Cai Jing· 2025-05-29 05:19
Group 1: Global Economic Landscape - The core focus of the global economic landscape is the rebalancing of inflation and debt, with countries experiencing divergent outcomes based on their debt levels [2] - The U.S. is facing the "Triffin Dilemma" and high fiscal deficit pressures, leading to increased market volatility [2][3] - Current U.S. economic indicators show resilience in consumption and investment, but inflationary pressures may complicate monetary policy [3] Group 2: China's Economic Recovery - China's economy is characterized by a "volatile recovery," with policy-driven consumption and manufacturing focusing on high-quality development [4][5] - The consumption market is rebounding, with retail sales growth of 4.7% year-on-year in the first four months of 2025, driven by policies like trade-in programs [4] - The manufacturing sector is transitioning towards high-end, intelligent, and green development, with significant contributions from technological innovations [4] Group 3: Macroeconomic Policy in China - China's macroeconomic policy is expected to become more proactive, focusing on "stabilizing growth, managing debt, and promoting transformation" [6][7] - Fiscal policy is set to increase, with a projected deficit of 13.9 trillion yuan and a deficit rate of 4% for 2025, alongside significant special bond issuance [6] - Monetary policy has room for further easing, with expectations for additional rate cuts and liquidity support measures [6] Group 4: Asset Class Outlook - In the asset class outlook, A-shares are seen as relatively undervalued compared to bonds, particularly in high-dividend and technology sectors [8] - Government bond yields are expected to have downward potential, with a flattening yield curve anticipated [8] - The RMB exchange rate is projected to remain stable within the 7.0-7.35 range, influenced by balanced factors [8] Group 5: Investment Strategy - Investors are advised to closely monitor policy trends and industry dynamics to identify structural opportunities amid volatility [9] - The global economy is expected to navigate through a phase of divergence between the U.S. and China, with the latter likely achieving a stable recovery through policy support and structural upgrades [9]
美元外汇储备占比降至30年来最低 欧央行行长呼吁把握时机提升欧元地位|全球金融观察
2 1 Shi Ji Jing Ji Bao Dao· 2025-05-28 15:00
Core Insights - The dominance of the US dollar is facing uncertainty due to geopolitical factors, with its share in global foreign exchange reserves at approximately 58%, the lowest since 1994, while the euro accounts for about 20% [1][2] - European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde emphasizes the need to strengthen the euro's international standing by enhancing geopolitical, economic, and legal foundations [1] - The euro has appreciated significantly against the dollar, rising over 9.5% since the beginning of the year, reaching its highest level since December 2021 [1] Group 1: Euro's Position and Challenges - Lagarde's call to enhance the euro's international status aims to promote trade denominated in euros, reducing Europe's vulnerability to unstable capital flows [2] - Despite the euro's recent strength, challenges remain, including lower European external debt issuance compared to the US and lower returns on euro-denominated assets, which hinder the euro's liquidity and market demand [3] - The potential for the euro to replace the dollar as a reserve currency is deemed unrealistic in the short term, as the US economy's fundamentals still outperform those of Europe [4] Group 2: Market Reactions and Future Outlook - The recent rebound in the US dollar index is attributed to a significant increase in the US consumer confidence index, which rose to 98 in May, marking the largest monthly increase in four years [5] - Analysts express caution regarding the dollar's future, noting ongoing concerns about US economic growth and budget deficits, which may limit the dollar's upward momentum [6] - Non-sovereign currencies, such as stablecoins and commodities like gold, are expected to play a more significant role in the future financial landscape, as they are less tied to a single country's fiscal policies [7]
美国衰落,不赖别人!早在50多年前,他们就给自己埋了一个大雷
Sou Hu Cai Jing· 2025-05-27 06:58
Group 1 - The core viewpoint is that the decline of the United States is evident, marked by the downgrade of U.S. debt ratings by major agencies, indicating a significant shift in its global standing [1][3] - The U.S. national debt has reached $36 trillion, with annual interest payments exceeding $1 trillion, projected to consume 6.7% of GDP by mid-century, highlighting an unsustainable debt situation [3][5] - The industrial hollowing out of the U.S. is irreversible, with its industrial output dropping from 40% of global production to 15%, significantly lagging behind China [3][5] Group 2 - The decline of the U.S. is both absolute and relative, with China's rapid industrialization and economic growth making the U.S. appear diminished in comparison [5][6] - The root causes of the U.S. decline are internal, particularly the unsustainable debt crisis and industrial hollowing, rather than external factors like China's rise [5][6] - The greed of capital is identified as a fundamental reason for the U.S. decline, stemming from the abandonment of the gold standard and the shift towards debt expansion [6][8] Group 3 - The U.S. faces inevitable trade deficits due to the need to maintain dollar hegemony, leading to increased borrowing and a worsening debt crisis [8] - The reliance on cheap currency for resource acquisition has contributed to the industrial hollowing out, making U.S. production less competitive [8] - The decline of the U.S. is deemed inevitable, with China's rise seen as a historical consequence rather than a primary cause [8]
不同寻常的美元周期——特征、机制与展望 | 国际
清华金融评论· 2025-05-26 10:44
Core Viewpoint - The current dollar cycle exhibits unprecedented characteristics, with its resilience surpassing historical experiences. This cycle shows three unusual behaviors: divergence from reserve currency share, divergence from fiscal and trade deficit expansion, and divergence from high inflation [2][3][7]. Historical Review and Current Characteristics - The dollar cycle has extended for 17 years since 2008, with a 40% increase, marking the longest uptrend since the Bretton Woods system's dissolution. The current dollar index peak exceeds the historical high of the 1990s [5][4]. Unusual Divergences - The first divergence is the decline in the dollar's share of global reserves from over 60% to just above 50% since 2015, despite a strong dollar index [7][10]. - The second divergence involves the fiscal deficit, which has reached nearly 15% of GDP, yet the dollar remains strong, contrary to traditional expectations [7][8]. - The third divergence is the occurrence of 9% inflation in the U.S. without a corresponding depreciation of the dollar, as other developed economies also face high inflation [10][11]. Mechanisms Driving the Dollar Cycle - The dollar cycle is influenced by fundamental, policy, and capital flow mechanisms, with geopolitical factors playing a significant role. The interaction between the real and financial sectors can lead to "overshooting" of the dollar cycle [3][13]. - The fundamental aspect is crucial, as the dollar index correlates with the U.S. GDP growth relative to other countries. The relative strength of the dollar is maintained as long as the U.S. economy performs better than its competitors [11][13]. Policy and Capital Flow Influences - The U.S. monetary policy's relative tightness supports the dollar, while international capital inflows, particularly into U.S. equities, have shifted from traditional treasury purchases [17][19]. - The dollar's strength is also supported by the unique structure of the U.S. economy, which has become less dependent on global trade, allowing it to withstand the negative effects of a strong dollar [14][15]. Potential Downturn of the Dollar - There are indications that the dollar may have entered a downtrend due to weakening relative advantages of the U.S. economy, increasing global competition, and structural changes in the asset-liability dynamics of the U.S. [20][21]. - The U.S. has strong incentives to seek a weaker dollar, as it can help address the rising current account deficit and manage its extensive foreign liabilities [21][23]. Future Considerations - The future trajectory of the dollar will depend on the internal correction mechanisms within the U.S. economy, influenced by various political and economic forces [26][27]. - The ongoing competition in technology, particularly with China, and the evolving geopolitical landscape will also play critical roles in determining the dollar's status as a reserve currency [27][23].