清华金融评论
Search documents
全球关税:起源、演进历程及对财政的贡献|国际
清华金融评论· 2025-08-17 08:58
Core Viewpoint - Tariffs have re-emerged as a focal point in global economic and trade policies, particularly due to the rise of trade protectionism in the U.S. and the reevaluation of tariff policies by multiple countries amid geopolitical conflicts and fiscal pressures [5]. Summary by Sections Origin and Characteristics of Tariffs - Historically, tariffs originated as a form of transit fee for cross-border goods, primarily aimed at controlling the movement of people and goods, rather than for fiscal purposes [7]. - Tariffs have evolved from being a minor component of national fiscal systems to a crucial tool for economic intervention and revenue generation, especially since the 16th century with the rise of international trade [8][11]. Functions of Tariffs - Tariffs serve three main functions: revenue generation, protection of domestic industries, and economic regulation [11]. - The role of tariffs has shifted over time, influenced by economic development and prevailing economic ideologies, with their revenue-generating function becoming less significant in developed countries [12][19]. Evolution of Tariff Systems - The evolution of global tariff systems can be divided into five main stages from the 16th century to the present, reflecting changes in economic thought and development levels [13][14]. - **First Stage (16th-18th Century)**: Mercantilism dominated, with tariffs primarily used for revenue collection [15]. - **Second Stage (19th Century)**: The rise of free trade theories led to a reduction in tariffs in industrialized nations, while developing countries continued to rely on tariffs for revenue and protection [16]. - **Third Stage (Early 20th Century)**: Protectionism surged post-World War I, reinforcing tariffs as tools for revenue and industry protection [17]. - **Fourth Stage (Post-WWII to 2017)**: Establishment of a global free trade system led to a general decline in tariffs and a shift towards income and consumption taxes as primary revenue sources [18]. - **Fifth Stage (2018-Present)**: A resurgence of protectionism, particularly in the U.S., has seen tariffs used again for industry protection and economic regulation [19]. Dependency on Tariff Revenue - Global economies can be categorized based on their dependency on tariff revenue, with developed economies generally showing low dependency (below 3%), while some developing economies exhibit medium (3%-5%) or high dependency (over 5%) [20][23][26]. - Countries like Japan, Canada, and the U.S. have low tariff revenue contributions to their overall fiscal income, while nations like the Philippines show a high reliance on tariffs due to weaker tax systems [23][28].
葛小波:关于中国财富管理发展思路的思考|财富与资管
清华金融评论· 2025-08-16 09:31
Core Viewpoint - Enhancing wealth management service levels is essential for achieving "financial people's nature" and promoting long-term investment strategies, ultimately aiming to build investor trust through diversified asset allocation and improved service capabilities [2][3]. Group 1: Current State of Wealth Management in China - The wealth management business in China is still in its early stages, with significant room for growth, as the demand from clients is high but the supply of effective services is lacking [18][19]. - Chinese residents' wealth has rapidly accumulated, exceeding 600 trillion RMB, with property income growing at an annual rate of approximately 8.5% from 2015 to 2023 [19]. - Despite the growth in wealth, the allocation of assets in capital markets remains low, with less than 20% of total assets invested in these markets, indicating a need for improved financial services [19][20]. Group 2: Challenges in Wealth Management - The depth of buy-side advisory services is insufficient, with the scale of fund advisory services still far below the potential of the wealth management business [24]. - Financial institutions face challenges in team building, asset allocation capabilities, product creation, and service tools, which need significant improvement to enhance client satisfaction and service quality [24]. Group 3: Development Trends and Opportunities - The transformation of wealth management in China has begun, with many institutions shifting from transaction-based services to a focus on long-term asset preservation and growth [21][22]. - The introduction of fund advisory services has established a new type of relationship between securities companies and clients, with over 60 institutions now qualified to offer these services, managing assets exceeding 150 billion RMB [21]. - The future of wealth management in China is promising, as financial institutions are encouraged to adopt a client-centered service model, optimizing their operational strategies to support residents in preserving and growing their wealth [20][22].
黄益平:如何打破低价内卷?|宏观经济
清华金融评论· 2025-08-16 09:31
Core Viewpoint - The article emphasizes the importance of brand development in the digital economy, highlighting two main paths: enhancing product quality and providing emotional experiences to consumers [1]. Group 1: Consumer Spending and Economic Growth - A significant challenge for the Chinese economy is to expand consumption, increase its share in GDP, and enhance its contribution to economic growth. Currently, only about 56 yuan out of every 100 yuan of GDP is used for consumption, which is approximately 20 yuan less than the international average [3]. - The low consumption ratio not only affects the quality of life but may also lead to oversupply and excess capacity issues. Additionally, there is a phenomenon of consumption downgrade, where the quality of consumer goods is declining [3]. Group 2: Quality Indicators and Market Dynamics - There is currently no effective indicator to reflect the quality of consumer goods. The CPI index has remained around -0.1%, which may indicate quality issues, but price does not always correlate with quality due to market supply and demand complexities [4][9]. - The "lemon market" concept by Nobel laureate George Akerlof illustrates the consequences of information asymmetry, where buyers focus on price rather than quality due to the difficulty in obtaining quality information [5]. Group 3: Solutions to Information Asymmetry - To address the lemon market problem, it is crucial to provide consumers with more information about product quality. This approach is applicable not only to the second-hand car market but also to other consumer goods, especially in e-commerce [6]. - A recent study developed two indices and a ranking system to inform consumers about brand quality and purchasing power, aiming to enhance the understanding of product quality alongside price [6][10]. Group 4: Brand Index Findings - The online consumer brand index in China has been slowly rising, indicating that consumption downgrade is not a universal phenomenon. Different industries show significant disparities in brand index values, with sectors like 3C, furniture, and beauty products having higher brand recognition compared to women's clothing [10][12]. - The average brand index is higher in new first-tier and second-tier cities compared to first-tier cities like Beijing and Shanghai, suggesting regional differences in brand perception and consumer behavior [10][13]. Group 5: Consumer Behavior and Economic Implications - The study found that cities with a higher proportion of migrant workers tend to have a higher brand purchasing power index but a lower average brand index, indicating a complex relationship between labor demographics and consumer preferences [14][15]. - The research also highlights that cities with stable populations tend to have higher average brand indices, while those experiencing significant population outflows may struggle with brand recognition and consumer spending [15]. Group 6: Emerging Brands and Consumer Trends - The study identified several emerging brands that resonate with younger consumers, such as Pop Mart and products catering to pet care, indicating a shift in consumer preferences towards quality and experience rather than just price [16]. - The overall conclusion stresses the need to focus on product quality information rather than solely on price signals, as brand importance is particularly pronounced in the digital economy [16].
中国首个再生金属衍生品(铸造铝合金期货和期权)上市的战略意义|资本市场
清华金融评论· 2025-08-15 09:30
Core Viewpoint - The launch of the first recycled metal derivatives, specifically casting aluminum alloy futures and options, marks a significant advancement in China's green finance market, providing a new perspective for risk management and supporting the development of the circular economy [2][4][8]. Summary by Sections Launch of Recycled Metal Derivatives - The Shanghai Futures Exchange has officially listed casting aluminum alloy futures and options, filling a gap in the domestic futures market for recycled metals [2][5]. - On the first trading day, the main contract closed at 19,190 yuan/ton, up 825 yuan/ton, a 4.49% increase from the listing price, with a total trading volume of 57,300 contracts and a transaction value of 11.01 billion yuan [5]. Industry Overview - Casting aluminum alloy, primarily made from scrap aluminum, is a key pathway for low-carbon transition, with energy consumption only 3%-5% of that of traditional electrolytic aluminum production [6]. - The carbon emissions from producing one ton of casting aluminum alloy are approximately 3.6% of those from electrolytic aluminum, saving 3.4 tons of standard coal and 22 tons of water [6]. - China's recycled aluminum production is expected to exceed 10 million tons in 2024 and reach over 18 million tons by 2030, with the new derivatives promoting standardized development in the industry [6]. Complete Aluminum Industry Chain - The introduction of casting aluminum alloy futures and options completes the risk hedging system for the aluminum industry, covering the entire supply chain from bauxite to recycled aluminum [7]. - Companies can now use these derivatives to manage risks associated with raw material costs and product price fluctuations, enhancing the resilience of the entire aluminum industry chain [7]. Green Finance and Risk Management - The emergence of casting aluminum alloy derivatives signifies a new phase in green finance, moving beyond traditional credit and bond products to include market-based pricing and risk hedging mechanisms [8][10]. - These derivatives allow companies to lock in costs for recycled materials and manage price volatility, thus enhancing operational efficiency and competitiveness in the low-carbon economy [8][10]. Innovation in Green Financial Products - The derivatives market introduces innovative functions for green finance, transitioning from single financing tools to comprehensive risk management platforms [11]. - The development of structured financial products that combine futures with green indicators, such as carbon emissions and recycling rates, is encouraged [16]. Recommendations for Financial Institutions - Financial institutions are advised to expand their green finance product offerings and enhance competitive differentiation, particularly in the carbon market, where China's trading volume is significantly lower than that of the EU [16][18]. - Collaboration between banks and futures exchanges is essential to create a comprehensive risk management system that supports the green transition of the real economy [15][18].
稳定币发展前景与全球金融治理体系变革 | 政策与监管
清华金融评论· 2025-08-15 09:30
Core Viewpoint - Stablecoins have become a focal point in the global cryptocurrency market, attracting significant international attention due to their higher value stability compared to traditional cryptocurrencies and their advantages in transactions and cross-border payments, which may lead to transformative changes in the global financial governance system [1][3]. Group 1: Development Dynamics and Characteristics of Stablecoins - Since the launch of Tether's USDT in 2014, the global stablecoin market has evolved through various phases, including rapid expansion and subsequent stabilization. Citi Institute predicts that by 2030, the total outstanding supply of stablecoins will reach $1.6 trillion, potentially making stablecoin issuers one of the largest holders of U.S. Treasury bonds [3]. - Stablecoins are categorized into four main types based on their anchoring mechanisms: fiat-backed, crypto-backed, algorithmic, and commodity-backed. As of May 2025, fiat-backed stablecoins have a market capitalization exceeding $220 billion, accounting for over 90% of the market share [4]. - The market structure of stablecoins is characterized by a dominance of USD stablecoins, which had a market capitalization of approximately $242.7 billion as of May 2025, representing 99.78% of the total market. In contrast, Euro stablecoins are below $500 million, with other currencies like the Turkish Lira and Japanese Yen having less than 0.1% market share [6]. Group 2: Application Scenarios and Expansion - The potential for stablecoins in cross-border payment settlements is significant, with estimated settlement values of $3.7 trillion in emerging markets in 2023 and projected annual growth of $5.28 trillion. Circle's CPN (Circle Payments Network) aims to integrate stablecoin usage into various payment sectors, enhancing their application in global payments [7]. Group 3: Risk Characteristics and Regulatory Trends - The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) highlights that stablecoins face systemic risks due to their reliance on volatile exchange rates, pre-paid cash issuance, and potential use in financial crimes. These factors hinder their ability to become a pillar of future monetary systems [9]. - Current regulatory frameworks, including the EU's MiCA, the U.S. GENIUS Act, and Hong Kong's Stablecoin Regulation, aim to address the risks associated with stablecoins. However, there are still regulatory gaps, particularly concerning non-fiat-backed stablecoins, and a lack of unified enforcement mechanisms [10].
刘元春:下半年经济怎么干?|宏观经济
清华金融评论· 2025-08-14 10:21
Core Viewpoint - The economic development in China during the first half of the year exceeded expectations, with a GDP growth rate of 5.3%. However, structural issues remain severe, indicating potential uncertainties ahead [2][3]. Group 1: Economic Growth and Structural Issues - The GDP growth rate of 5.3% in the first half of the year reflects a stronger-than-expected economic performance, but structural problems are still significant, as indicated by data from June [2][3]. - Investment remains crucial for stabilizing growth, as evidenced by the data from the first half of the year [7]. Group 2: Consumer Demand and Policy Measures - Expanding consumer demand is a strategic priority for China, which requires systemic adjustments rather than short-term stimulus measures. Key areas include ensuring residents' income, asset balance, and social security systems [5]. - Various policies have been introduced to support consumer spending, including subsidies for education and services for vulnerable groups, which are expected to continue in the second half of the year [6]. Group 3: Investment and Market Dynamics - The slowdown in real estate and private investment growth in June poses a significant challenge for the second half of the year. To counter this, measures to stimulate private investment and improve expected returns are being implemented [7]. - The government is focusing on enhancing the space for private investment and ensuring that the expected returns for private enterprises are safeguarded through fiscal and monetary policies [7]. Group 4: Market Competition and Innovation - The phenomenon of many companies not being profitable despite advancements in technology and industry upgrades highlights the need to address disordered competition and market chaos. This requires actions to ensure effective competition and sustainable profitability for enterprises [8]. - The initiative to combat "involution" is essential for optimizing market order and addressing the macroeconomic issues of low price levels and supply-demand imbalances [8]. Group 5: Foreign Trade and Investment Stability - The political bureau meeting emphasized the need to stabilize foreign trade and investment, acknowledging the changing landscape of international trade, particularly concerning U.S. tariff negotiations [9][10]. - The emergence of "black swan" events and extreme situations necessitates preemptive measures to mitigate potential impacts on foreign trade [11]. Group 6: Consumption Policies and Future Expectations - The "old-for-new" program has a total budget of 300 billion yuan, with over half already implemented in the first half of the year. The remaining budget is expected to expand in scope and variety, including new consumer goods and services [12]. - Future policies will focus on enhancing consumer potential and ensuring that consumption support measures are effective in the medium term [12]. Group 7: Risk Management and Urban Development - The emphasis on high-quality urban renewal indicates a shift in policy focus to address changing risk dynamics, particularly in the real estate sector, which is moving towards a new development model [13]. - The adjustment of real estate policies aims to reduce risks and promote stability in the market, reflecting a proactive approach to managing economic challenges [13].
这个夏天,“邮”你来辩|第二届中邮保险•紫荆杯全国高校金融普及教育辩论赛初赛圆满落幕
清华金融评论· 2025-08-14 10:21
Core Viewpoint - The article highlights the successful completion of the preliminary round of the second "Zijing Cup" National College Financial Education Debate Competition, focusing on themes such as digital economy, silver-haired industry, inclusive finance, and digital finance [1][6]. Group 1: Competition Overview - The preliminary round featured debate teams from 48 universities across the country, with 24 teams advancing to the next round [1]. - The event was organized by Tsinghua Wudaokou in collaboration with China Post Insurance, showcasing the engagement of young talents in financial discourse [1]. Group 2: Debate Themes - The debates centered on critical issues including the role of young people in upgrading the silver-haired industry, emphasizing the need for professional capability leapfrogging and intergenerational equity [11][23]. - Discussions on digital finance highlighted the necessity of balancing business transformation efficiency with risk prevention, stressing that a robust regulatory framework can accelerate high-quality development [12][13]. Group 3: Key Insights from Judges and Participants - Judges noted the complex mindset of young participants, who seek both professional growth through technological advancements in elder care and emotional fulfillment from their contributions to society [7]. - Participants argued that the silver-haired industry requires a shift in perspective, recognizing elderly individuals as active societal participants rather than passive recipients of services [23]. Group 4: Financial Culture and Economic Service - The debate emphasized that the sustainable development of China's financial culture relies on adhering to the fundamental purpose of serving the real economy while adapting to innovations in the digital economy [18][20]. - The importance of opportunity equality in inclusive finance was highlighted, asserting that without it, sustainability becomes meaningless [15].
养老金风险转移(PRT)市场对我国二、三支柱发展的启示|财富与资管
清华金融评论· 2025-08-13 08:55
Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the development of pension risk management in Europe and the United States, aiming to provide insights for the development of the second and third pillars of pension insurance in China [2]. Group 1: Pension Risk Transfer (PRT) Overview - PRT is a financial arrangement where companies transfer the payment responsibilities of defined benefit (DB) pension plans to insurance companies, aiming to reduce risks such as longevity risk, investment risk, and interest rate risk [4][5]. - The emergence of the PRT market in Europe and the U.S. is driven by multiple factors, including aging populations, accounting standards requiring market value measurement of pension liabilities, and the complexity of pension asset-liability management [5][6]. Group 2: Historical Development Stages - Initial Stage (Pre-1980s): Pension plans evolved from informal commitments to structured DB plans, with companies facing increasing financial pressure due to aging populations and investment volatility [8]. - Emergence Stage (1980-2000): The introduction of regulatory frameworks like ERISA in the U.S. and the establishment of PBGC laid the groundwork for PRT transactions, with early examples like General Motors' group annuity transaction [9][10]. - Growth Stage (2000-2015): The PRT market saw accelerated development due to advancements in actuarial technology and regulatory support, with significant transactions such as General Motors transferring $25 billion in pension liabilities [14][15]. - Boom Stage (2015-2025): The U.S. and U.K. markets experienced explosive growth in PRT transactions, with notable deals like AT&T's $31 billion transaction in 2022, pushing annual PRT transaction volumes to new highs [16][17]. Group 3: PRT Mechanisms - Buy-in: Companies purchase annuity contracts from insurers to cover pension liabilities while retaining legal responsibility on their balance sheets [22]. - Buy-out: Companies transfer pension liabilities to insurers, removing these liabilities from their balance sheets entirely [22]. - Longevity Swap: A financial agreement that transfers longevity risk from pension plans to insurers, which can further transfer this risk to reinsurers [22][23]. Group 4: Role of Insurance Companies - Insurance companies play a crucial role in the PRT process by taking on pension liabilities and managing longevity risk through various financial instruments, thus transforming their role from asset managers to long-term liability bearers [26][28]. - The development of a multi-layered risk transfer structure involving insurers and reinsurers enhances the capacity for managing longevity risk and supports the evolution of pension systems [28]. Group 5: Challenges in China - China's pension system primarily relies on defined contribution (DC) plans, lacking the historical context of DB plans that facilitate risk transfer, leading to a deficiency in systematic longevity risk management capabilities [30][31]. - The absence of a robust regulatory framework specifically addressing pension liabilities and longevity risk hampers the development of a comprehensive risk management system in China's insurance industry [30]. Group 6: Recommendations for Development - To establish a pension risk transfer mechanism in China, it is suggested to leverage the third pillar of the pension system, focusing on transforming individual accounts into lifetime annuity products [36][38]. - The creation of a national pension reinsurance platform is recommended to facilitate risk sharing and enhance the capacity of insurance companies to provide long-term guarantees [38].
银行业的“内卷”与“反内卷”|银行与保险
清华金融评论· 2025-08-13 08:55
Core Viewpoint - The phenomenon of "involution" is spreading in the financial sector, leading to excessive competition among banks, which has prompted regulatory actions to restore a healthy market order [3][10]. Group 1: Definition and Characteristics of Involution - Involution refers to a situation where individual entities continuously invest resources without achieving systemic efficiency improvements, resulting in diminishing returns and overall inefficiency [5]. - In the banking sector, involution manifests as irrational market behaviors, including price wars, homogenized business models, and ineffective assessment systems [7]. Group 2: Causes of Banking Involution - The mismatch between supply and demand, along with the deepening of interest rate marketization, contributes to banking involution. There is a structural contrast between accumulating deposits and shrinking credit demand [8]. - The Loan Market Quotation Rate (LPR) mechanism has led to a market-driven pricing system, but the simultaneous decline in credit demand and LPR has pressured banks' net interest margins, pushing them into irrational price competition [8]. Group 3: Consequences of Involution - Involution is eroding the operational safety margins of banks, compressing interest margin revenues, and potentially weakening the ability to accumulate capital internally. The average net interest margin of commercial banks fell to 1.43% in Q1 2025, down 75 basis points from historical highs [9]. - The intensification of scale-driven competition has led to a relaxation of risk management standards, increasing the likelihood of asset quality deterioration and higher non-performing loan rates [9]. Group 4: Responses to Involution - Following the central government's call to regulate irrational price competition, various banking associations have implemented measures to curb involution, such as establishing governance frameworks and self-regulatory agreements [11]. - Banks are encouraged to adopt differentiated operational strategies and enhance service value to regain competitive advantages, focusing on product innovation and customized solutions [13]. Group 5: Future Directions - Strengthening the legal and regulatory framework is essential to address irrational competition, with a focus on enhancing enforcement and establishing rapid response mechanisms for competitive misconduct [13]. - Optimizing internal assessment mechanisms and fostering innovation talent are crucial for banks to transition from scale-based evaluations to multidimensional performance metrics, thereby enhancing service quality and customer satisfaction [14].
宋志平:如何克服内卷|宏观经济
清华金融评论· 2025-08-12 08:48
Core Viewpoint - The photovoltaic industry in China has achieved remarkable success but is now facing challenges such as price declines and reduced profitability, prompting the need for internal adjustments to overcome industry "involution" [2]. Summary by Sections Involution and Competition - "Involution" has become a significant issue across various industries, necessitating a re-evaluation of competitive philosophies and the establishment of new competition rules [3]. - The distinction between healthy and unhealthy competition is crucial, with the latter often leading to value destruction. The recognition of "involution" as a form of harmful competition has gained consensus [4]. Industry Self-Regulation - Industry self-regulation is essential, with associations playing a key role in promoting self-discipline among members. This includes industry planning, policy formulation, technological innovation, and combating unfair competition [6]. - The importance of leading enterprises in setting examples for self-regulation is emphasized, fostering a collaborative ecosystem among businesses [6]. Mergers and Acquisitions - Mergers and acquisitions are vital for enhancing industry concentration and overcoming involution. Historical examples from the U.S. steel industry illustrate the benefits of consolidation [8]. - The advantages of mergers include strengthening enterprises, improving company quality, facilitating innovation, and increasing industry concentration [9]. Capacity Management - The photovoltaic industry faces a significant supply-demand imbalance, necessitating both production cuts and capacity reductions to stabilize prices and maintain profitability [10]. - Historical practices in the cement industry demonstrate that production limits can effectively balance supply and demand without adversely affecting overall sales [11]. Pricing Strategy - A shift from a volume-based to a price-based profit model is necessary, emphasizing the importance of maintaining pricing power rather than solely focusing on sales volume [12][13]. - Effective pricing strategies can significantly impact profitability, and companies should avoid relying on sales personnel for pricing decisions [14]. Innovation and Value Creation - To transition from a competitive "red ocean" to an innovative "blue ocean," companies must focus on differentiation, market segmentation, high-end product development, and brand building [15][16][17][18]. - The emphasis on innovation is crucial for enhancing product quality and achieving competitive advantages in the market [19].